Fingerprints do more than bust us

Posted on Tuesday, June 23, 2009 3:53 PM PT

By Bill Briggs

We are our fingerprints.

From the loops on our thumbs to the whorls on our pinky toes, no human shares the same delicate swoops on the skin of our palms and feet. But those inimitable wrinkles on our digits didn’t develop just to let us access keyless doors, or bust us for being at the scene of a crime. What is the biological purpose of those tiny, raised crinkles?

It’s long been thought that the distinct skin patterns reduce surface friction when we’re grasping or holding objects — that the the friction improves our grip. However, British researchers have found that fingerprints actually make it more difficult for people and primates to grip and hold flat, smooth things.

Mary Altaffer / AP

“Because the skin is ridged, a lot of the fingertip isn’t touching the surface,” explains lead researcher Dr. Roland Ennos, a biomechanics expert at the University of Manchester in England’s faculty of life sciences. “Think of the tires on a Formula 1 race car, or on an Indianapolis car. They want to have the best grip as possible, so they use flat tires. In just the same way, our fingertips – because they are ridged – don’t have the same grip they would if they were perfectly flat.”

To get a better grasp of the science, Ennos’ team built a contraption that looks a little like a guillotine. A sheet of Perspex (a plastic also known as Plexiglas) was hung from a cross beam. The beam was then lowered and raised while student Peter Warman held the strip between the fingers and thumb on his right hand. While measuring the force of his clasp on the Perspex, the machine pulled the strip down via a weighted plastic cup. The team tried three different widths of Perspex as well as three different grip angles to mathematically separate Warman’s own pressing force from the contact area, and to weed out any variables.
Their research, published in the June Journal of Experimental Biology, found the student’s fingerprints added slip, not grip.

Humans aren’t the only creatures with skin prints, either. Why do koalas have them? Why do monkeys in South America have similar prints on their tails? Ennos has a theory.

The padded sections of our hands and feet that do the toughest physical work – grabbing, twisting, pushing, pulling and thrusting – are laced with prints. The grooves and ridges give those swaths of our skin more elasticity. They allow the skin to stretch and distort as the labor takes place. The opposite is true of the smooth areas of our hands and feet. After withstanding excessive friction, they rip or collect fluid between the skin's various layers.

“When you do ‘DIY’ work or when you’re walking with ill-fitting boots, it’s the areas which haven’t got the ridges that tend to get blisters,” Ennos said. “My idea is that by having fingerprints, the skin is actually about twice as flexible. It struck me that having a fingerprint is part of a design package that strengthens the skin, allowing it to deform an awful long way without being damaged.”

Ennos believes that fingerprints also allow us to more easily grab rougher surfaces and wet objects while they also add sensitivity to our feel. But touch cannot be their main function, he theorized, because the heel is covered with skin ridges yet “isn’t used to discriminate anything” if, say, we’re trying navigate a dark room.

The British researcher has applied for additional funding to conduct extra tests on the friction-prevention qualities of our fingerprints. But here’s a warning to all interested student subjects: Blisters are part of the job.

Comments

Why would they study a smooth surface?

When fingerprints evolved man was not working with smooth surfaces, most surfaces in nature are not smooth (tree branches, rocks, shells).

If you use the analogy of the tire, the more irregular the surface that you are driving on, the more grooved the tires.
"It’s long been thought that the distinct skin patterns reduce surface friction when we’re grasping or holding objects — that the the friction improves our grip."

That sentence doesn't make sense. Reducing friction improves our grip?
Just like race car tires, smooth surfaces make for poor traction on wet surfaces (as discussed in the article). We humans sweat, on our hands and ridged areas as well. Without ridges to provide traction, we would slip a lot more.

Me, I love my radial whorls!
I think you mean 'increase' surface friction.

"It’s long been thought that the distinct skin patterns reduce surface friction when we’re grasping or holding objects"
OMG!!! I have fingerprints, too!!!
Lame.  How much did that cost somebody/some organization?
I'm surprised the researchers would have thought that the ability to grasp smooth objects would have had any evolutionary advange.  Few objects that are not man-made are smooth.
Brilliant deduction and research!!  Thank you!
Very interesting read - makes a lot of sense.  I have never thought about that as an explanation.
Since evolution would have had us do more gripping of rough objects than of smooth objects, the "fingertip ridges are there for grasping" proposition still seems to be sound.  If primates encountered predominantly Perspex in their environment and still had fingertip ridges, then it would be confusing.  It seems that the "elasticity" proposition provides an additional benefit of the ridges: a both rather than either/or approach perhaps.
The analogy to racing tires is flawed. Too many variables between the tire compound, racing surface, speeds, downforce, etc.  I would think that the analogy would best work against his idea. Gheckos have enormously detailed ridges on their feet which allows them to cling to sheer surfaces.
Another example of academics with nothing constructive to do.  
WELL, A FEW STATES..."HAVE MINE"... GUESS, I'LL HAVE TO  BURN MY FINGER TIPS OFF?  JUST A  JOKE HOMO LANDINSECURITY... I MEAN HOMELAND "WHATEVER"  THEY ARE ALL IN CO-HOOTS.
Starting with the premise of the smooth racing tire (F1, IRL, NASCAR, etc.) and claiming that smooth is stickier on smooth surfaces is, at best, a leap. You will find that those tires are quite "sticky" because the "rubber" is quite sticky. They are not grooved because they want maximum contact area with the track/roadway surface and they do not have to deal with getting water out from under the contact area with the road/track. Some of these tires are so soft that rubber can be pealed off by pushing your thumb accross the tire surface (and look at the rubber left on the racing surface by these tires (often the stuff is referred to as the marbles because driving on them reduces surface contact so much it is like driving on marbles.

Different materials have different coefficients of friction. Consider Teflon, which is quite smooth and very slippery. If our skin surface was akin to Teflon picking anything up would be very tricky indeed. In contrast, if our skin was like the surface of the racing tire, it would be easy to pick things up (but harder to put them down). But the surface would wear away at a fairly high rate.

The grooves and ridges MIGHT help the skin stretch and distort more easily, but the material properties of the skin (or any other material) determine the elasticity more than the ridges, which are not folds. As people age the ridges do not go away, but the elasticity of the skin decreases substantially.

Truly, as with car tires, the grooves do help increase friction with wet surfaces.
Homeland Security says we don't own our Fingerprints..they are "Public Domain".  I disagree and will not submit to their tyrannical measures!
My fingerprints belong to me!
Is this going to change anything ? No .lets spend the  additional funding  something useful.
My theory about fingerprints is two-fold. Perhaps God gave us all unique fingerprints, as well as DNA, to emphasize how special we are to Him; that each person was carefully considered and individually complex. Secondly, because God is a lover of justice, our prints help our legal system identify criminals.
We needed to waste money on this useless research for what purpose?
God is a wonderful designer. Thanks for the confirmation!
I still find it hard to believe that no two people can have the same fingerprints.There is only a finite amount of patterns to be had and I think the number of people on this planet outweight the number of patterns.
And why don't Indy cars race in the rain? Because those slick tires that provide such great grip on dry surfaces from all that contact area offer no such assurances on a wet surface. And why do normal passenger car tires have treads on them?  Because, unlike Indy Car drivers, we can't be assured the road surfaces are going to be perfectly dry whenever we drive on them.  When is the last time your company shut down for the day because of rain???  Tires for everyday use must be suitable for wide variety of conditions.

I submit that fingerprints are an evolutionary equivalent to "All Purpose Radials".  Not the best solution for one instance (like an Indy racing slick), but a pretty good design for handling wet, dry, frozen, or whatever types of objects.
Amazing isn't it? Man has had fingerprints throughout all time, but we only started using  and recognizing that in the last century. How many other medical cures are waiting at our fingertips (excuse the pun)?
That is a great theory, still leaves the question as to why are fingerprints individually different, if it was purely to reduce friction everyone would have the same fingerprints.  Unless nature still testing the concept and have not chosen the best design, yet.
Interesting. But how many surfaces in nature are as smooth as perspex? Or the fact that skin itself is elastic. Now on the other hand the seperation of the ridges in the print would allow for a wider griping surface when extended, then contracting to grip what ever surface ones grasping. For the heel since its an extreme impact and load bearing surface, one wouldnt really want too much discriminatory sense in the area.
The article makes no sense! I can grasp the elasticity thing etc. but why are all of them different from one another? Name another part of the body that is so specialized that it is different from everyone elses. Maybe I missed something here.   Carlos
Fascinating
"part of a design package"?  

This guy ain't no scientist, he's one of those crazy creationists!
I enjoyed reading this article. I hope they get the funding.  
Just as slick racing tires are NEVER used in the rain, fingerprint ridges also act like a high performance tire by channeling water and heat from the contact patch.  
If cavemen didn't have friction ridges on their feet, when they ran in the rain they would have slid right into the dinosaur's mouth.  Caveman Joe also didn't have rain gloves and had to use his bare hands when climbing trees and rocks in rain.
We have fingerprints by intelligent design. In fact, every distinguishable, distinct, and defining feature of the human body was created by our Creator who lovingly and graciously reveals Himself through nature (natural revelation) and the Bible (supernatural revelation). God gaves us unique fingerprints to remind us that every person is special and wonderfully made, even those yet unborn, still in the mother's womb. Fingerprints give each person a unique identity, and helps us reach out and touch the face of God. When God feels our fingerprints, He smiles and is well pleased.
Some defining work, for sure, but how many times have you seen substances as unnaturally smooth as Perspex in nature, that are not wet.  That is where most of the evolution to the fingerprint would occur, especially if you were say a monkey or an ape.  Don't rule out the grasping theory yet...
 Enjoy the fruits of your labor God said to us. God knew we would have to labor to serve him and our family.And you correct that no human shares the same because Gods creation was to make us all individual souls.Its impossible that all of this just happened on its own, its to complicated to figure out everything,but scientists and researchers keep trying to find the final answer but they never will until they just have faith and believe in  THE LORD THY GOD.
 
We have fingerprints also because God is letting us know in His own way that He cares about us individually.That He created us individually and wants to have a personal relationship with us.
As the Psalmist ,King David put it:"He knows the way I walk."  So,certainly ,we have a unique footprint on our heels ,each and every one of us ,which gives a more profound meaning to this phrase from the Bible.
Dr. Ennos....
Trust me, having been born with a genetic disorder that precluded me from having fingerprints(Dermatopathia Pigmentosa Reticularis), those of us without them can't grip smooth objects or turn pages very well. I'm assuming that you took into account that the ridges are actually thousands of tiny sweat glands also, which has been supposed to assist with grapsing.
The article makes no sense! I can grasp the elasticity thing etc. but why are all of them different from one another? Name another part of the body that is so specialized that it is different from everyone elses. Maybe I missed something here.   Carlos
Did a scientist say "design"? Hmmm. Design package- interesting phrase, I wonder what he is getting at. What would happen if he took that line of thought to its logical conclusion? And how did the evolution community let it through? Hmm.
Smooth skin surfaces DO add grip, but they also would have a greater tendency for layers of skin to remain attached to the gripped item as it slipped from the hand.  Fingerprints allows the gripping to be done with the force of the hand muscles and reduces the chance of epithelial skin loss.  The article needed to clarify the potential for skin damage.
You said, "having a fingerprint is part of a design package".  This is just one more proof that humans are a product of magnificant design, no evolution.
that sounds a little far fetched.  remember when you take long baths or get into a pool, your fingertips wrinkle up because they're absorbing the water and therefore stretching.  once they've absorbed all the water they can, they begin to wrinkle and become distorted due to excess water.  well, when you are a baby floating in amniotic fluid, your fingertips absorb liquid then as well.  keep in mind that the fluid is not stagnant and moves around as both the mother and baby move.  this ebb-and-flow swirling of the fluid is what creates the distinctive ridges and patterns of everyone's fingertips, or fingerprints.  if flexibility were the main reason, then most animals with tails would have prints on them as well.    
That makes sense, that ridges make flexibility possible.  In fact, with long wood pieces, the crosscutting of ridges enables the bending of that wood.  So if I take a 2 inch by four inch by eight foot piece of lumber, and cut the 2 inch depth to about 1 and something inches, and do it repeatedly close enough to leave something looking like a comb, the previously inflexible length of wood will bend.  Make sense???
OK, you explained the function, as all good scientists do. However, the WHY and HOW our prints developed such complicated and close whorls - those are still in the realm of the mysteries of creation. The Creator chooses to keep His "whys" and "hows" pretty well hidden.
Silly science. Very little that is smooth and flat occurs naturally. The ridges and swirls on our hands do help tremendously in what humans have needed to do for millions of years. Try doing everyday things in surgical gloves to see what life would be like without fingerprints.
This is junk science. Most arguments, like those  related to friction, violate physics and the rest violate the plain common sense. Have you seen fingerprints on ones foreskin? Yet it stretches a good ten times. Try it with the skin on your hands. Another example of wasting taxpayers’ money through grants given by government to pseudo-scientists.
Huh?  Reduces or increases friction?
This is yet another fantastic witness to the Creator of the universe!
Cool. Same concept as bark on trees. It contracts and expands from cold and heat better than a smooth surface.
What is DIY work?
Good thought process. The idea regarding flexability is sound logic. I agree with your assertation that fingerprints are part of a design package. That would inherently imply the wisdom of the designer, would it not?  
The creationists (smooth brain) in the crowd are again grasping at straws to explain (by supernatural intervention) something that is inherently difficult to explain without a scientific (convoluted brain) method. More surface area = better grasp of reality...less surface area = less grasp of reality. :)

DIY is do-it-yourself Pat, DUH!
Unique like our irises, our nervous network, our hair follicle pattern, degree and distribution of pigmentation, our blood vessel patterns,our dna etc Unique in a similar way to other animals that reproduce sexually rather than by parthenogenesis. ie with two sexes rather than creating genetically identical 'clones' as aphids and some frogs can and bees etc.Uniqueness is normal, having identical fingerprints would be limited to genetically identical twins.


Send a comment

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.): 

Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private)

About the blog

Insights and ruminations on the strangeness of all things medical, pharmaceutical and biological.

Msnbc.com writers and editors will muse upon the wonderfully weird human body and the medical curiosities that make you go huh, ewww or ouch! Looking for informed, unhinged meditations on everything from dubious diseases to recipes for ersatz mucous? Well, this is the place.

If you have a question, e-mail The Body Odd.

Archives


Add this blog to your news reader