The curious case of the stone baby

Posted on Wednesday, March 04, 2009 10:59 AM PT

By Diane Mapes

While a 92-year-old woman delivering a 60-year-old baby may sound like a bizarre plot twist from the movie “Benjamin Button,” it’s true. Huang Yijun, 92, of southern China, recently delivered a child which she’d been carrying for well over half a century.

The baby wasn’t alive, however. The woman was carrying a lithopedion — or stone baby. It's a rare phenomenon that occurs when a pregnancy fails and the fetus calcifies while still in the mother’s body.

According to Dr. Natalie Burger, endocrinologist and fertility specialist at Texas Fertility Center, lithopedions start off as ectopic pregnancies, a condition where the fertilized egg gets stuck on its way to the womb, implants and develops outside the uterus.

“Usually an ectopic pregnancy will mean a [fallopian] tubal pregnancy, but in a small percentage of cases, the pregnancy can actually occur in the abdominal cavity — in places like the bowel, the ovary, or even on the aorta,” she says. “These are very rare locations and they can be very dangerous.”

In most cases, Burger says, doctors will recommend the pregnancy be terminated due to the extreme risk to the mother. Or the fetus will simply die on its own due to a lack of blood supply.

“The vast majority never get anywhere close to multiple months of pregnancy,” she says. “They die, the tissue breaks down and they’re gone.”

In certain cases, however, the implanted fetus gets to an advanced stage before it dies. Too large to be absorbed by the body, the remains of the child or its surrounding amniotic sac slowly calcify, turning to stone as a way to protect the woman’s body from infection from the decomposing tissue. Because the mother’s body doesn’t recognize the hardening mass as foreign, if there are no other complications she can basically just go on with her life.

Stone babies are extremely rare, but you wouldn’t know it considering how often they’ve been used as a plot device in novels, short stories and TV shows. For example, in recent years, they’ve shown up on “Law & Order: Criminal Intent,” “Nip/Tuck” and the Australian series, “All Saints.” Maybe calcified babies are so popular because they tap into a mythological fascination with or deep fear of a soft, innocent body turning to stone.

According to a 1996 paper in the Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, only 290 cases of lithopedion have ever been documented by medical literature, the earliest being that of a 68-year-old French woman Madame Colombe Chatri who, when autopsied after her death in 1582, was found to be carrying a fully-developed stone baby in her abdominal cavity. Chatri, whose abdomen was said to be “swollen, hard and painful throughout her life,” had been carrying her stone child for 28 years.

The mean duration of a “stone pregnancy,” according to the Journal article, is 22 years. Some women, such as China’s Huang Yijun, have carried their calcified fetuses for more than 50 years.

How could a woman walk around with a stone baby for years and years and not realize something was amiss?

“In some cases, there would be symptoms of an early pregnancy and then they would go away,” says Burger. “The women would just think they just lost a pregnancy and wouldn’t think any more of it.”

In other cases, a lack of money or medical resources comes into play. Huang Yijun told reporters she didn’t have the money to have her fetus removed after doctors told her it had died inside her in 1948. So, she simply “did nothing and ignored it.”

Other women, particularly those living in countries where obstetric care isn’t readily available, are unaware of their condition until the calcified mass causes a serious health issue. According to Burger, lithopedions — which can weigh up to nine pounds in the case of a full-grown fetus — have been known to cause intestinal obstruction, pelvic abscess, problems with delivery in future pregnancy and fertility issues, among other things.

They’ve also been known to cause quite the public sensation.

In 1582, the autopsy findings of Madame Chatri – complete with illustrations depicting the woman and her stone child — became an instant medical bestseller and the calcified fetus was quickly sold to a wealthy French merchant (sort of the P.T. Barnum of his day) who put it on display at his museum of curiosities in Paris. The fossilized fetus reportedly changed hands several times after that, finally ending up in the King of Denmark’s royal museum in 1653. Two hundred years later, the museum was dissolved and the stone fetus was transferred to the Danish Museum of Natural History.

Several years after that, the stone baby was lost. Or perhaps laid to rest, at long last.

Comments

Holy crap.
Article does not say how she had the baby, what started the delivery of the baby, etc.  It would be nice to know that part of the story
Stone Baby... sounds like a good name for a band.
This is crazy.....  awkward
wow thats weird
Mum,
This I have never heard of this before either.
Shell
Matt--well done.
This is an awesome story.  Did they take the baby out of the woman surgically?  92 is pretty old to be going under the knife...  wonder what she did with it.
I agree totally with Stacie from Seattle and Matt from Portland!
OH  MY GOD THAT COULD HAVE DEEN ME I HAD TUBAL PREGNANCY 5 YRS AGO.
Would grow up to be a great poker player.
Matt, that is hilarious.  A band name is genious.
I bet it would make a cool gargole.
To Terri Jo in Akansas:

Well now Terri don't you know that that 92-year-old lady started having contractions?  And it was a blessed birth from the vagina.  And with her little, frail, brittle bones, she pushed for hours and hours and then that little stone baby came right out ripping up her insides and breaking her pelvic bones.

Come on now, really, are you that naive?  

Wow.  That's nuts.  
Wait for Obama to get hold of this. The baby will become a victim and Obama will get the tort lawyers on the case. Someone will pay somewhere.
Crazy!!
D:  That would suck having to carry around a 9 pound stone.
i agree, great name for a band :)
woah dude thats creepy! dude Imma name a band that :PP
ooww snaap
I have to second Stacie's comment of Holy Crap!!
I've seen it on discovery Chanel it's crazy that this woman went this long and is so old wouldn't a surgery like this be a risk at her age?  
Sounds like a combination of sci-fi and something gothic--like a gargoyle inside someone.
very interesting.....
On the bright side, at least the parents were able to skip that whole "rebellious teenager" phase.
Stone Baby ROCKS!
does women ever die from this situation?
this was a law and order episode years ago. now you know where to go for science lessons.
"Delivery" would have been by way of c-section or other similar extraction.  She would not have undergone labor or contractions.
Holy crap is right.  This is the craziest thing I've ever heard of.  
My mother, who passed away in '92, told me that the same thing happened to my grandmother.  Apparently, my grandmother was pregnant with baby #10 at the time and witnesses one of her other children struck by a drunk driver.  She says the baby turned to stone.  I was never sure about it.  Sounds like it's plausible.  Not that the baby turned to stone because of the horrifyig accident my g-ma witnessed, but I guess it could have happened.  I'm going to ask one of my aunts.  Interesting.
Wouldn't a dead fetus in your body for over 60 years smell?


Amazing! I happen to see this air on television. It's truly amazing what a woman body can endure. When God made woman, he made something beautiful.
Makes one think what else is there for us to know about. AND to boot it all - all this suffered by a woman.
this is toooo weird!
I saw a documentary on Discovery Health and they actually performed surgery to deliver the baby.  The baby had calcified and turned hard and grew to her insides.  That is why it is called a stone baby.  They said it is the body's way of protecting itself from the harm that the fetus could have caused her.  She was sick but not as sick as she could have been.
I heard about something like this to a woman in India. (discovery channel or something) A woman who got pregnant in the 1940's had the same thing. She had the baby cut out after about 50 or so years. she knew she was pregnant but she had complications. But at the time in India, no one could do such a surgury, so they just let her be. In the 1970's or 80's they operated on her and got it out.
Where is the father?
oh no. the doctors who discovered that the baby had died and didn't want to over a solution need to be ashamed of their act. please doctors where life is involved do the neccesary, the doctors put this woman's life at stake. thanks to God and whoever helped the poor woman out.
oh no. the doctors who discovered that the baby had died and didn't want to over a solution need to be ashamed of their act. please doctors where life is involved do the neccesary, the doctors put this woman's life at stake. thanks to God and whoever helped the poor woman out.
Interesting! :)
Akward Turtle
So that explains my beer belly. Oh wait, I'm a guy.
They had a show about this on either discovery health or TLC.  It was about an elderly woman in the Middle East, I think.  She had gone full term with her pregnancy as a young woman and had started the labor process.  Eventually the labor stopped and no baby.  The baby calcified and wasn't removed until almost 50 years later when she started complaining of severe abdominal pain. Turns out that the pregnancy had been in the abdominal cavity.  
The article says upon her autopsy the calcified baby was found/delivered.
Weird, weird, WEIRD! :S Lol really.
Teri Jo, from what I remember, she was having more pain than usual and when she finally went to the doctor it was first though to be a tumor.  It was surgically removed.  She never "had" the baby.
Rock on.
Stranger things have happened.


Send a comment

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.): 

Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private)

About the blog

Insights and ruminations on the strangeness of all things medical, pharmaceutical and biological.

Msnbc.com writers and editors will muse upon the wonderfully weird human body and the medical curiosities that make you go huh, ewww or ouch! Looking for informed, unhinged meditations on everything from dubious diseases to recipes for ersatz mucous? Well, this is the place.

If you have a question, e-mail The Body Odd.

Archives


Add this blog to your news reader