Blimey! Why the sandwich made Briton swoon

Posted on Wednesday, January 14, 2009 5:37 PM PT

By Jasmin Aline Persch

You may think some sandwiches are scary – a Wendy’s Baconator, anyone? — but for one young British woman, eating a sandwich really was a dangerous act.

The otherwise healthy 25-year-old from Birmingham, England, regularly fainted while eating sandwiches or drinking fizzy sodas. Once while having a bit of grub behind the wheel, the young woman blacked out at a red light. Fortunately, she came to before the signal switched to green.

Having experienced the condition since she was 15, she realized a connection between certain foods and the fainting spells.

Image: Body Odd

When she sought medical help, doctors didn’t recognize the curious symptoms. She was hospitalized several times and her blood, thyroid and pituitary glands were extensively tested, but everything was normal. She didn't smoke, drank only a little and didn't use drugs. Doctors suspected the problem was all in her head. They didn't realize that the glitch was in her heart.

“Because she’s young, everybody thought, ‘It can’t be her heart,’ ” said Dr. Howard Marshall, a cardiologist at University Hospital Birmingham who detailed her case with Dr. Christopher Boos in a recent article, dubbed “Dangerous sandwiches,” in the British medical journal The Lancet.

The University Hospital Birmingham doctors discovered that when she became light-headed, she was suffering a complete atrioventricular block, a delay in the electrical signals between the upper and lower chambers of the heart. It caused the pauses between her heart beats to last up to 2.5 seconds, Marshall said. 

The doctors discovered the young woman suffers from a rare disease called “swallow syncope,” a condition that causes the patient to lose consciousness when too little blood flows to the brain. Only about six cases have ever been reported, said Marshall, who has seen one other case besides this one. Swallow syncope was first recognized about 50 years ago, yet remains fairly mysterious due to its rareness, Marshall said.

Other cases have been linked to gastric disorders or problems with the esophagus. For this young woman an anatomical anomaly had caused the nerve systems in her throat and heart to intertwine in her brain stem. When she would take a big bite of a sandwich, a bolus -- or ball -- formed in the back of her throat. The “cross reaction” between her throat and heart in her brain that caused her heart to halt briefly starved her brain of blood long enough for her to pass out, Marshall explains.

During the medical exam to confirm the diagnosis, doctors had her eat various foods to find the link. One of the culprits? A ham sandwich, which the young woman had brought in herself.

Cold fizzy drinks and solid foods are the most common triggers, but there are others.

  • In 2005, a German medical journal described a 38-year-old man who fainted while drinking hot coffee.
  • In 2006, Japanese doctors detailed a 66-year-old woman whose heart stopped while she swallowed soup or sipped tea.
  • In 2007, an American doctor wrote about a 68-year-old woman who fainted while standing at the sink, gulping a glass of milk.

Swallow syncope has been described as a “potentially lethal disease,” but Marshall said that the young woman would not likely have died from the condition. “She had enough phyical warning to spit out the sandwich and stop herself from falling over,” he told msnbc.com.

Marshall, who helped confirm her illness, said the young woman’s diagnosis brought not only physical, but emotional relief. She had endured years of fruitless medical examinations and meetings with psychiatrists after doctors questioned whether the symptoms stemmed from her imagination.

“I knew it wasn’t in my head. I knew it was real,” was her response to the diagnosis, Marshall recalled.

Rather than giving up ham sandwiches or soda for life, the young woman had a permanent pacemaker implanted to regulate her arrhythmia.

Because the condition had led her to eat very sparingly, the 5-foot-4-inch woman weighed only 102 pounds before the pacemaker was implanted last February. Now free of fainting spells, she’s no longer limiting her portions, or sandwiches. As a result, she' packed on a few pounds.

“You didn’t tell me I would put on half a stone in weight,” Marshall recalled her saying, using the British phrase “stone,” meaning 14 pounds.

Comments

Check out Dysautonomias; they are disorders of the autonomic nervous system that cause some types of syncope.
To Erica

LOL, was just hinking about "house !"  
13 years ago I flatlined 3 times after "dieing" over a period of 6 hours.  My heart just stopped. It has happened 3 times before but my heart would start up again by itself.  This time it didn't. At the ER they couldn't figure out what was wrong, other than my EKG was blipping about every 5 seconds.  I had a pacemaker installed and was told I, too, have a short in the electrical system from my brain to my heart.  It was never attributed to food.  But they never gave me a reason.  Who cares, I'm on my second pacer and it's kept me alive for 13 years.
I have vasovagal syncope. It's similar, except I faint if my body is under a lot of stress, such as when I'm very sick or I'm in a lot of pain.
perhaps that's what caused Elvis to die - yes, I'm serious
how long before this is a diagnosis on 'house'?
There was an episode on some medical show once that was about a guy whos heart stopped and he passed out when he drank cold water.
Last February, I fainted while sitting and eating a piece of bread.  Everyone thought that it was due to poor eating habits - too big of bites and bot chewing my food enough before swallowing.  I am running not walking to my doctor to find out how I can confirm atrioventricular block.
Almost a year ago, I fainted after choking on cold ginger ale.  I stopped drinking carbonated drinks months earlier, so this was different for me.  I was out for 5 minutes.  Placed in the hospital and tests for my heart were performed.  No reasoning for the fainting spell was given.  Maybe this is my answer to a puzzling event in my life.
I have been having this for over 5 years and no one knew what my problem is?This is exactly what I do soda water and foods I know when the blaclouts are coming on and try to hold on to table I have fallen in my plate and on the floor.
I was so amazed to receive this info. I have fainted a few times after drinking a very fizzy cold soda.  I take a large drink then realizing it is so "bitey" that I swallow the whole thing in one large gulp. The pain is so great that I have passed out.  I always thought it was a pain reflex, not caused by a lack of blood.  After scaring my husband to death, I am extremely careful when I drink soda.
LOL Erika. I was thinking the same thing! This will end up on "House" sure enough!
This has happened twice recently to my son, who is a healthy,strong 25 yr.old young man.  We were at a restaurant in VA, (we live in TX, but work all over the country), and had just finished breakfast. We had just been discussing him taking over the driving for me and all of a sudden, he put his head in his hands and said he was sleepy, and then his head fell backward and I realized he was not breathing. My husband and were yelling his name and sorta slapping his face and lowering him to the floor to start CPR. While I was shouting to the waitress to cal 911, he let out a big snore sound and the we realized he'd started breathing again.  When he opened his eyes, it was obvious he wasn't really aware. (He told me later, he knew he was on the floor, knew he shouldn't be on the floor, but didn't know what to do about it.) The paramedics that came were excellent, and so thorough, but baffled.  They checked everything..blood sugar, vitals, etc., but didn't have a sure diagnosis.  We took him to Martha Jefferson , an Urgent Care kind of facility there, where they did a CAT scan of his head, an EKG, an EEG, blood and urine tests,everyting short of a spinal tap, and every test was perfectly normal, but for a slightly elevated blood pressure that he's on medication for already.  The doctor said she was expecting to walk in and see an older man given the information, and was surprised to find he was only 25.  He also went to see his family doctor once he was home, who found nothing, but was willing toset him up with the specialists, but we don't even know with whom to start...cardiologist?..neurologist?..endocronologist?   Any more info would be greatly appreciated!!  jbbrower@hotmail.com  
I have had this happen many times. mostly when I am tired or stressed out, sometimes 2 times in one meal. never passed out but have had everything go black. Dr called it a vagel response problem I also have Cardiomyopathy.
Wow.  Micturition syncope.  It has a name.  Since I was a kid this has happened to me.  Mostly at night.  I just figured I'm tired and the effort to go was what casued the fainting, as I never really had a problem during the day. Except if I'd been napping.  Worst case was kind of a delayed reaction.  I was walking back to bed and passed out.  Almost cracked my head open on the bed rail.  Who knew.
I have a friend who is 30 now and the Dr's still don't know why he passes out. He wakes up in excruciating pain.
I don't know if this the correct forum but I've looked & looked for info to no avail. Whenever I have richer than normal food & some alcohol by the end of the meal I have a major sneezing fit. Why? It started out years ago with very rich food (such as at special occasions) & red wine but it's mutated to also any indulgence. So if anyone is familiar with this I'd love to know what you know.
 Now we know this isn't as rare as they say and can help those who didn't know how or why this was happening. This is why we need to TALK to each other. Peace and love everybody!  -Tek    
My daughter, whom is now 24 yr old, has Vaso Vagel Syncope which is another one of those "Syncope" problems. She would pass out when she stood still, hit the florr,loose control of bodily functions(which can be quite embarrasing), this  back a few years while attending college classes. One Cardiologist wanted to put in a pace maker which we opted out after visiting another. A Heart specialist(Eletropysiologist) at Greisinger HEart Center in Danville, PA got her on the road to recovery with adjusting her daily routines, diet(adding salt to everything), certainly to learn to never stand still by rotating back and forth to each leg while having to address a croud while speaking or socializing. She is under control now but has a bad weight gain but continually says active to avoid having a syncope escapade. Drs told her she may grow out of it, but she doesn't want to wait to see if it is gone. We were at three heart docs in three Different areas of the state,East, West and South and finally got two that agreed on the treatment of the one in Danville. It's very scary to go through ,but persistance paid off.
I have reguarly had my throat feel like it was closing and have passed out maybe 8 times in my life.  Each time I have been out only a few seconds before comming too.  I am 74 and this has been going on since 1964.
too much eating is bad especially the food which not contains a lot of vitamins!so..eat well like fruits and vegetables.
Various people and physicians have different experiences with syncope or some not at all.  Trying to live in a world where it isn't understood is difficult if you happen to experience it pretty often.  Mine hasn't been connected to food or beverage intake.  Tests finally revealed that my cortisol levels are low in the mornings.  It is sort of like having the U.S. daylight savings time when an hour is taken from your morning schedule every day for decades until you discover the problem and hopefully a solution.  I don't know which is worse.  The problem or the lack of understanding about it.
There are so many things that cause people to pass out, you could spend the rest of your life being tested for them all. If it recurs frequently, any doctor would order a 24 hour EKG and a 24 hour EEG to find out exactly what is happening just before the syncopal episode. These simple and common tests would have easily picked up this problem.
don't you just love the "it must be in the patient's head" when the docs can't figure it out or are so judgemental that they don't do, as mentioned before, a cardiac workup! It sounds like British healthcare.
I have had a very similar event. My research led me to something called Vagally Mediated Atriofibrilation. It had been bothering me for around a year or so when I passed out and was hospitalized. My cardiologist never heard of it until he saw me. I quit all caffiene products and cut way back on meat and fried food. After about 9 months of diet change, I no longer had any detectable heart flutter. Been near 2 years since the hospital and feel good. I believe that excessive caffiene was the main cause of my condition. I also think this type of condition is more common than thought-just very difficult to diagnose. The cardiologist was amazed that I could create a-fib by simply eating a banana. He asked me to do it again several times in a row and each time he was shocked. And now, it simply does not happen anymore.It was so bad that almost anything I swallowed caused me heavy head-even my saliva. Most of us would feel a lot better w/ the proper diet.    
You'd think after fainting for 10 yrs, she'd have figured out not to eat while driving or doing other dangerous activities.  What an idiot.
for what it's worth...

"vasovagal" is the correct spelling and it's the vagus (not Vegas!) nerve which is affected.

silki, the baconator thing was a joke by the author(s) of the article.  That's not what the woman was eating.

and I can't believe several of you have given email addresses.  You're asking for trouble doing that.  Mailboxes overloaded with spam yet??  
when i see pamela anderson naked, i get such a boner that it makes me pass out from blood loss to the rest of my body

does that count?
Goodness, seems like the world needs to train more Houses - as in - diagnostic specialists.  
Any time someone answers, "Oh my gosh, that happened to me ONE TIME too."  IT DOES NOT MEAN YOU HAVE A PARTICULAR DISEASE STATE.  Doctors/Health Professionals base diagnosis and therapy on EVIDENCE BASED MEDICINE... What is being described by all of the comments on this site are ANECDOTES.  Evidence based medicine requires enough data to support a statistically significant connection between life variables.  Anecdote means, a particular or detached incident or fact of an interesting nature; a biographical incident or fragment.  That is why your doctor's eyes glaze over when you come up with 15 different cause-effect relationships in your every day life based upon individual stories you have experienced or been told.  9 out of 10 times, you're COMPLETELY wrong.  Have fun, and see your doctor regularly.
Why is it that when doctors can't figure something out, it must be all in your head. How pompous are they really, that they just can't admit when they don't know why something is happening to a person. I wonder how many people have died because " it was all in their head"? Or at least that's what their doctor said when he/she couldn't figure it out.
I have had this very thing happen 2 times this past year, but without completely fainting - just on the edge.  Now I know what probably caused it as I am reasonably healthy and my experience was much the same as in this article.  Good to know it has a name.
I was just diagnosed with Neurocardiogenic Syncope. I had no idea what caused it. The first time i passed out I was in a Dr's office after receiving a shot. We all believed it was the shot that made me pass out. Then it happened again while I was staning line at the movies. I went to one doctor and he sent me to a neurologist. The neurologist sent me to get a tilt table test done. It only took me about 10 min to pass out ( which according to the nurse is quick). I'm on medication now and drinking a lot more water and gatorade to keep by blood pressure up.
I wonder if I have a mild form of this. All my life I've had a strange, disoriented, disjointed feeling whenever I swallow something like honey or fudge sauce, or something with that sort of texture. Oddly enough, though, the same thing happens with some external stimuli, like having something furry stroked over my cheek or jawline.
Cutie and others,

There is a condition called Orthostatic Hypotension which will cause you to faint or feel faint when standing up after you have been sitting or laying.  It's common in people who typically have low blood pressure.  I've experienced it for years.  My doctor suspected that Orthostatic Hypotension was my problem, and it was confirmed when I was in the hospital for another reason and stood up - and promptly hit the floor!
I agree with the lady who said "if the doctor can't find the answer, he says its all in your head".  For several years, I asked 3 different doctors about my problem and none of them could help me, told me by one of them it was all in my head.  Well, in one way he was right.   It was the neurotransmitters that werent working properly, but this was before they came out with a diagnosis called "manic depressive" or "bipolar depression".  I was so happy to find out the disease had a name, that I was not going crazy, and that now there was a medication to help.  Doctors only know what they learn in med school and too many of them don't continue their medical education to keep up with things.  Its too bad but maybe someday, they will say, I know you have a problem but I don't know what the answer is.
gloriamwilliams207@hotmail.com, You should be checked out for gluten sensiivity and celiac disease.
It's not lupus!
Some of your comments are really annoying guys. I don't know if you're kidding or not but if you've passed out once when you've happened to be eating something it's most likely NOT because you have this disease, it was most likely some other random reason. And especially if that happened to you after drinking 30 BEERS. Guess what? I think that'd happen to anyone who drank 30 beers.
I once passed out after drinking 4 vodka and orange juice then going to the gym for a work out. wow, I will never do that again.
I have this weird condition no one can seem to diagnose when I'm nauseated ALL THE TIME and eating any amounts of food can cause me to throw up everything I've eaten. It happens when I eat certain foods but not all the time. I do my best to prevent myself from throwing up. Had it since I was very tiny.
No fainting spells though. Perhaps a variant?
Shane in AZ, stone is a unit of measure in Britain...where the article is about. And it is 14 pounds. Weighing scales all have the measure in stones on them. Obviously you don't use it in the US but there is life outside of North America.
Plain white rice gives me hiccups.
blimey mate! That is the first time I have heard of eating sandwiches and fainting!!!
TO ANON  - I have been fainting since childhood and was diagnosed with vaso-vagul syncope - neurocardiogenic syncope- you name it  I 've had three tilt table , ekg's holter monitors from one day to one month - i finally found a cardiologist who put me on atenolol 25 mg for a very mild begnin arythmia and have not had any symptoms since (its been 5 yrs)My daughter has the same problem and hers is controlled by high salt diet. All I can say is taht is not OK to just live with it - find another doctor if yours is not doing the right thing. -
The stone used to wiegh a person's weight in Britain has it's origins in ancient times it was originally used for weighing agricultural commodities against the known weight of a stone. Historically the number of pounds in a stone varied by commodity, but eventually it was agreed that a stone equalled 14 pounds, and was standardized at that weight.
Excellent site. It was toothsome to me.  
bodyodd.msnbc.msn.com - go to my favorites!!!


Send a comment

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.): 

Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private)

About the blog

Insights and ruminations on the strangeness of all things medical, pharmaceutical and biological.

Msnbc.com writers and editors will muse upon the wonderfully weird human body and the medical curiosities that make you go huh, ewww or ouch! Looking for informed, unhinged meditations on everything from dubious diseases to recipes for ersatz mucous? Well, this is the place.

If you have a question, e-mail The Body Odd.

Archives


Add this blog to your news reader