Blimey! Why the sandwich made Briton swoon

Posted on Wednesday, January 14, 2009 5:37 PM PT

By Jasmin Aline Persch

You may think some sandwiches are scary – a Wendy’s Baconator, anyone? — but for one young British woman, eating a sandwich really was a dangerous act.

The otherwise healthy 25-year-old from Birmingham, England, regularly fainted while eating sandwiches or drinking fizzy sodas. Once while having a bit of grub behind the wheel, the young woman blacked out at a red light. Fortunately, she came to before the signal switched to green.

Having experienced the condition since she was 15, she realized a connection between certain foods and the fainting spells.

Image: Body Odd

When she sought medical help, doctors didn’t recognize the curious symptoms. She was hospitalized several times and her blood, thyroid and pituitary glands were extensively tested, but everything was normal. She didn't smoke, drank only a little and didn't use drugs. Doctors suspected the problem was all in her head. They didn't realize that the glitch was in her heart.

“Because she’s young, everybody thought, ‘It can’t be her heart,’ ” said Dr. Howard Marshall, a cardiologist at University Hospital Birmingham who detailed her case with Dr. Christopher Boos in a recent article, dubbed “Dangerous sandwiches,” in the British medical journal The Lancet.

The University Hospital Birmingham doctors discovered that when she became light-headed, she was suffering a complete atrioventricular block, a delay in the electrical signals between the upper and lower chambers of the heart. It caused the pauses between her heart beats to last up to 2.5 seconds, Marshall said. 

The doctors discovered the young woman suffers from a rare disease called “swallow syncope,” a condition that causes the patient to lose consciousness when too little blood flows to the brain. Only about six cases have ever been reported, said Marshall, who has seen one other case besides this one. Swallow syncope was first recognized about 50 years ago, yet remains fairly mysterious due to its rareness, Marshall said.

Other cases have been linked to gastric disorders or problems with the esophagus. For this young woman an anatomical anomaly had caused the nerve systems in her throat and heart to intertwine in her brain stem. When she would take a big bite of a sandwich, a bolus -- or ball -- formed in the back of her throat. The “cross reaction” between her throat and heart in her brain that caused her heart to halt briefly starved her brain of blood long enough for her to pass out, Marshall explains.

During the medical exam to confirm the diagnosis, doctors had her eat various foods to find the link. One of the culprits? A ham sandwich, which the young woman had brought in herself.

Cold fizzy drinks and solid foods are the most common triggers, but there are others.

  • In 2005, a German medical journal described a 38-year-old man who fainted while drinking hot coffee.
  • In 2006, Japanese doctors detailed a 66-year-old woman whose heart stopped while she swallowed soup or sipped tea.
  • In 2007, an American doctor wrote about a 68-year-old woman who fainted while standing at the sink, gulping a glass of milk.

Swallow syncope has been described as a “potentially lethal disease,” but Marshall said that the young woman would not likely have died from the condition. “She had enough phyical warning to spit out the sandwich and stop herself from falling over,” he told msnbc.com.

Marshall, who helped confirm her illness, said the young woman’s diagnosis brought not only physical, but emotional relief. She had endured years of fruitless medical examinations and meetings with psychiatrists after doctors questioned whether the symptoms stemmed from her imagination.

“I knew it wasn’t in my head. I knew it was real,” was her response to the diagnosis, Marshall recalled.

Rather than giving up ham sandwiches or soda for life, the young woman had a permanent pacemaker implanted to regulate her arrhythmia.

Because the condition had led her to eat very sparingly, the 5-foot-4-inch woman weighed only 102 pounds before the pacemaker was implanted last February. Now free of fainting spells, she’s no longer limiting her portions, or sandwiches. As a result, she' packed on a few pounds.

“You didn’t tell me I would put on half a stone in weight,” Marshall recalled her saying, using the British phrase “stone,” meaning 14 pounds.

Comments

I have that problem when I drink Soda pop.  I cann't swallow and I have been know to pass out and or have a seizure.
How long before this is an episode on House?
"stone" isn't a British phrase, it's the most used form of measurement here. I only know my weight in pounds because of American websites.
i have episodes of tachycardia, usually brought on by being overheated and have found that sometimes a thick, cold drink (like a milkshake) will "shock" my heart back into a normal rhythm.  My mom has issues with rapid heartbeat as well, however, she has the exact opposite experience.  Milkshakes have caused her to have tachycardia, while hot drinks seem to help her normal rhythm return.  Weird.
I can remember a girl in junior high school would faint for no particular reason.  She had a great mother so I'm sure she had been examined - this remined me of the girl in homeroom.
This happened to me once eating mexican food and washing it down with a big swallow of beer.  I was in a restaurant and passed out for about 10 seconds before coming to.  I fell out of my chair and people were huddled over me.  I was fine afterward.

My question is, do I have the disease "swalow syncope"?  or was it just a one time thing?
wow ive never heard of that b4
cardiac work up including holer monitoring is part of sycopy....most of trained physician will do that.
I had a case of micturition syncope, which would be worse if it happened frequently.  Its when you faint when you pee.  Had it happen once in my life.  The doctor knew what it was and I am very careful now, lol.

Nothing like people standing over you in the restroom saying "You okay?" as you're waking up, lol.
As an RN for 21 years mainly in ERs i have never seen a patient with this syndrome.  However , the elderly and people with heart disease have been known to pass out or even die in the bathroom from stimulating the same nerve.
There are probably many people with this disorder who simply stopped the particular food consumption behavior after a couple of bouts of fainting. It may not be as rare as believed.
I was diagnosed with neurocardiogenic syncope...I have been fainting since age 6 from multiple situations: digestion syncope is one of the many as well as standing or sitting too long...the tilt table test can diagnose your fainting issue if you have any of these odd symptoms....just a thought
I have Supraventricular tachycardia, which can start and stop with no apparent reason, but have told my doctor that the act of drinking can bring on an episode.  I don't think I have this problem, however I do think there is more of link between the esophagus and heart then is the current medical belief.
Allrighty then
Leamington Spa?  Where are you from?  Where is "stone a typical unit of measure?
Don't know if I have that or not,but I can't eat bread and some other things because it makes me feel so bad.Anyone know why???
glomar, Shelbyville Tn
Hahahaha I was thinking the exact same thing: This should be an episode of House.
This is happening to me for about 2 years, The last time I was driving and passed out and struck a parked car in the rear.  No one was hurt.I have had many test on the heart and can't find anything which  cause it. A 30 day heart monature also. Any sugestions.
blimy blokes!
The Brits drink, the Japanese sip, and the Americans GULP - is there a little bias in the article against Americans? Other than that, an interesting article.
I saw an episode of St. Elsewhere a couple decades ago where this guy has gas syncope. He would faint everytime he farted or took a dump. Finally, they discovered why and implanted a pace maker. Now he could have a constitution without fainting!
My Husband passes out when he eats Ice Cream and has since childhood and hes 62 years old now.
my mom is having these spells and drs think she has symstoms of heart attack and or mini strokes but everything checks ok but blood pressure and all shows signs of heart problems.  is this what she is having.  it is getting more frequent as she gets older.  it is really scaring us.  as i read this it sounds like it could be her.  how could we find out for sure.  we live in west plains missouri.  where is the closest place to check for this.  her specialist are in springfield, missouri.
I get tachycardia episodes and have had some triggered by hot drinks or hot soups. I feel for anyone with any sort of heart conditions.
My daughter, whom is now 24 yr old, has Vaso Vagel Syncope which is another one of those "Syncope" problems. She would pass out when she stood still, hit the florr,loose control of bodily functions(which can be quite embarrasing), this  back a few years while attending college classes. One Cardiologist wanted to put in a pace maker which we opted out after visiting another. A Heart specialist(Eletropysiologist) at Greisinger HEart Center in Danville, PA got her on the road to recovery with adjusting her daily routines, diet(adding salt to everything), certainly to learn to never stand still by rotating back and forth to each leg while having to address a croud while speaking or socializing. She is under control now but has a bad weight gain but continually says active to avoid having a syncope escapade. Drs told her she may grow out of it, but she doesn't want to wait to see if it is gone. We were at three heart docs in three Different areas of the state,East, West and South and finally got two that agreed on the treatment of the one in Danville. It's very scary to go through ,but persistance paid off.
Wow! The human body is amazing , isn't it??
Same symptoms except there isn't any specific food or drink that causes the heart stoppage.  I too have had a pacemaker installed - runs about 4 to 5% of the time.  My condition has changed as I have become older, now it's hiccups, usually three and they are very painfull.  Twice I underwent every test they could think of, including at the Mayo Clinic when they were trying to find the cause - the result?  "Live with it!"
Wow. That's new to me.
After going through EKG's, Cardiac Stress tests,Holter Monitors X2 this article sounds like the answer to my problem.  I've been told the strange episodes of feeling like I'm going to pass out may be due to Ventricular Tachycardia.  The episodes are so short and happen at very irregular intervals that nothing has shown up as of this date.  I'm due to have a EPS study to see if can stimulate this - if not a temporary monitor will be implanted for up to 18 months to see if this can be captured with that.  May lead to a pacemaker. These happen 9 out of 10 times right after eating.  But my sister is one of the few that survived a Sudden Cardiac Death episode, we want to be sure there is no genetic component to what ever these are.  Hope to find out something soon. Thanks for this article.  
My Irish cousins and other family members use stone too.  I thought it was 11 lbs, but see that it is 14.
Hi, I have the fainting problem when I stand after being seated for even a short time.  Docs cannot tell me why and it is very debilitating.  Any help out there?

Cutie, Kingston, Jamaica
yes i had many years of fainting spells everytime i ate bread or pasta or anything made with flour, no doctors could find out what was wrong, a dietician told me it was an allergy, and i was tested and i am allergic to Buckwheat in Flour, now i am much better thanks to a dietician .
This once happened to me while taking shots of Tequila.  After the 23rd shot I passed out
wow! i've passed out from many things but never from eating a sandwich.
Several years ago, I was told I suffered from Vago-Vago.  I fainted while being fitted for contact lenses.  The eye doctor had no idea why.  Later, an MD told me that when he massaged my eyes (closed of course) my heart slowed down.  He said the Vegas nerve connects many parts of the body and we still don't know how it reacts to many things.
I fainted after eating tunafish.  My twin sister also fainted after she ate a tunafish sandwitch.  I no longer eat tunafish.  I was told it was to much protein for my body to handle at once.  If you have low blood sugar, which I do.  
I've had this problem for the past eight years. I have pasted out in restaurants and at home. Once ending up in the ER because I hit my head on a table when I collapsed out of a chair. My sister also has this problem. I can't believe other people have this too!
I fainted once after swallowing 30 beers. I woke up several hours later with a headache and dehydration. Do I have this rare disease?
i get hiccups every time i drink soda, and almost every time i drink anything, if i gulp. (i try not to but sometimes can't help it.) i also get hiccups very easily when swallowing my first bite of a meal. it's like my esophagus isn't telling my stomach to get ready to receive, and this delay causes the hiccups, every day, at least once. i can imagine if her heart and throat were accidentally intertwined... maybe there is something here that SHOULD be sending/receiving messages simultaneously but isn't. anyone have any suggestions?
In my case it was never diagnosed.  I'd spent the night with a co-worker I was "seeing".  We walked four blocks to a restaurant.  While we were waiting to be served, I went to the men's room. I passed out at least twice, perhaps three times.  After the last time I came to with paramedics hovering over me. I felt fine except for being scared and feeling humiliated. The lady and I left. This happened in the 1979 and never happened again.
My 92 year old mother has recently been getting dizzy & extremely light headed to the point of nearly passing out after she eats breakfast (usually). She is on several medications for an irregular heartbeat, high blood pressure & other conditions relevant to old age. We (including her doctor) assume that the faintness is probably side effects to the meds. This article relating this condition makes more sense. She feels fine when she gets up in the morning & she even feels fine after she's taken her meds. Some of the meds require that be they be taken with food; and it's the food part that makes her nauseated & dizzy. So, there ya go...what's to help when you're 92 & have heart & kidney failure?
My daughter has (sp?) vasal-vagal syndrome which also causes random fainting. They say (that somethings undefind) cause a "startle" reaction that constricts blood flow and causes a similar reaction.
I am a Fifty eight year old woman and I have had the same symtoms as that disease for the past ten years or longer I  will blinkout when I drink acidity drinks real fast and eat white meat such as chicken breast. I thought I had acid reflux disease.
Excellent post David Fishken.

I have a condition (congenital hyperreninemic hypoaldosteronism) that the literature says is very rare and that the adults who are finally
diagnosed are generaly "fine."  But, we aren't fine and nor are we counted by anyone...

Too, most doctors that patients get to see, no matter how rare a condition, do not write it up, nor report it to anyone.  Sometimes, they might tell a couple of colleagues...

Why is it when a doctor can't figure something out he/she automatically assumes it must be in your head?!  I was puking sick for my entire pregnancy and the docs couldn't figure it out - so assumed I must be doing it to myself.  After having my child, it started again and it turned out I had gall stones, which no one bothered to check for when I was pregnant!  Idiots (to quote House).
I have had bouts of SVT for years.  Had all the heart tests, which were negative.  I told the doctors it was not heart, that I felt it much be GI because right before the rapid heart beat starts, there is the sensation of something coming from my abdomen up into my chest.  Had EGDs, colonoscopies, swallow studies, etc.  Finally, had a test and sliding hiatal hernia was noted, and was diagnosed with delayed gastric emptying.  I just finally decided that the hernia was sliding up, setting off a spasm I guess that in turn causes the heart to start beating rapidly.  Now, when I have the feeling of something trying to come up into my chest, I tighten my upper abdominal muscles as tight as I can, and most all the time now, it pushes it back down and keeps the heart from beating rapidly.  It works 99 percent of the time.  I'm glad I didn't listen to my family doctor who tried to put me on heart medicine.  I kept insisting it was GI.  
I used to go into convulsions and pass out.  They checked my heart and told me I had a heart cliche(spelling).  The described it to me that my heart beats slow, normal and fast, never consistent.  Is this the same?  It all seemed to stop after I stopped working with my sister(stress).  I have however, been diagnosed with acid reflux.  It is so bad to the point it has affected my voice for the last 3 years.  Some days I dont have a voice.  Are the 2 realated?
My 23-year-old son has gone into seizure then passed out while eating carne asada burrito from a local mexican restaurant on two occasions.  He didn't go to a hospital or clinic, but he doesn't eat that anymore, alone anyway.  I think it is more common than thought because it isn't reported.  
I have a hard time swallowing pills but I can't imagine having it cause my heart to stop! It's bad enough when the pill gets half stuck in my throat.
well of course after eating alot of baconators will put on pounds! thats common sense? no problems now eating them huh? be careful what you eat i;d say :}


Send a comment

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.): 

Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private)

About the blog

Insights and ruminations on the strangeness of all things medical, pharmaceutical and biological.

Msnbc.com writers and editors will muse upon the wonderfully weird human body and the medical curiosities that make you go huh, ewww or ouch! Looking for informed, unhinged meditations on everything from dubious diseases to recipes for ersatz mucous? Well, this is the place.

If you have a question, e-mail The Body Odd.

Archives


Add this blog to your news reader