When it comes to breasts – three’s a crowd?

Posted on Monday, December 22, 2008 3:16 PM PT
Filed Under:

By Diane Mapes

While many men and women have strong opinions about the size of breasts, most would agree the number of their breasts — two— is  fine.

Unfortunately, for those with polymastia, that’s not always the case. 

Sometimes referred to as accessory breasts, polymastia is the presence of supernumerary (extra) breasts on the human body. The extra breast tissue can appear in many forms, everything from a third nipple (the most common condition, referred to as polythelia) to a fully-formed — and  fully-functional breast — in some unusual location on the body. It can also present itself as a breast with a nipple but no areola, a breast with an areola but no nipple, or just a small lump of breast tissue with neither nipple nor areola.

Image: Body Odd

It’s not as rare as you might think, according to a recent article in The American Surgeon. Up to 6 percent of the general population has accessory breast tissue, although it is commonly misdiagnosed, usually as lipoma, a benign tumor composed of fat cells. In a few cases, supernumerary breasts can be diagnosed with breast cancer. Women report a much higher rate of polymastia and polythelia than men, but there have been several reported cases of men with accessory breast tissue. Extra nipples are more common.

Actor Mark Wahlberg has a third nipple, which he considered removing but eventually decided to keep. According to the blog, thesuperfluousnipple.blogspot.com (where “three is a magic number!”), other triple nippler guys include Jackson Browne, Brian Jones of The Rolling Stones, Frank Langella, and the fictional characters Krusty the Clown (“The Simpsons”) and Chandler Bing of “Friends” (Chandler had his superfluous nipple surgically removed).

Much less common (and less celebrated, perhaps) are the cases of men with fully-formed accessory breasts. In 1980, the Journal of American Academic Dermatology reported the highly unusual case of a 74-year-old man with a normal female breast on the back of his left thigh. According to the article, he told researchers he’d had the “fatty tumor” almost all his life and it had “never caused a problem.” He also refused to have his accessory breast removed.

In women, supernumerary breasts and nipples are usually found on the embryonic mammary or “milk line,” i.e., the ridge that extends from the armpit to the groin. Famous female supernumeraries include the Greek goddess Artemis. More recently, Tilda Swinton, Lily Allen and comedienne Moms Mabley have owned up to sporting a spare nip.

According to Dr. Anne Burdick, professor of dermatology at the University of Miami, Miller School of Medicine, the most common location for accessory breast tissue is in the axilla (or armpit).

“The extra breast tissue is usually in one armpit or the other, but it can exist in other areas, as well, including the mid-chest, the sternum, the back, or even in the genital area,” she says.

Indeed, cases of aberrant breast tissue have been reported on the back of the neck, the buttock, the vulva, the hip, the shoulder, the perineum (the region between the anus and the genitals) and the mid-back. A 1997 article in the Journal of Pediatric Surgery describes an incident of supernumerary breast tissue on the face (it was removed for cosmetic reasons). A 2006 case study in the Dermatology Online Journal describes “the first report of supernumerary breast tissue on the foot.” 

While in many cases, it’s a matter of one extra breast or nipple, there are instances of four, five, six or seven supernumerary breasts and/or nipples. In 1886, a doctor reported a woman with eight extra breasts — 10 in all. There was no word on how many children she nursed.

Interestingly, many women with polymastia are unaware of the condition until the tissue begins to respond to hormonal fluctuations brought on by menstruation, pregnancy or lactation, as the extra tissue gets bigger and more tender just like the normal breast.

“A patient will come in for acne and I’ll do a full body exam and notice it,” says Dr. Burdick. “When I ask them questions, it will turn out that it gets bigger with their period and is uncomfortable.”

Accessory breasts have also been known to lactate. One of the most famous cases in history is that of Therese Ventre of Marseilles, France, who had an extra breast on the outside of her left thigh. According to the 1827 report, the extra breast enlarged during puberty and produced milk when she became pregnant; a woodcut from the era shows her nursing children both at her breast and her thigh. 

As is often the case with odd body phenomenon, men and women with supernumerary breasts and nipples were tortured and killed during the European witch hunts. Extra nipples were thought of as “witch’s teats,” used to nurse a familiar (a witch’s helper). Even Anne Boleyn, the unpopular second wife of Henry VIII, was said to have either an extra breast or extra nipple (along with an extra finger), although this may have just been bad press.

These days, polymastia and the more common polythelia are hardly considered a mark of the devil, but a stigma does remain for some, especially men.

“It can be very disturbing to a man to discover that he has accessory nipples, even more so, accessory breasts,” says Dr. Hema Sundaram, a Washington, D.C., dermatologist who has performed liposuction on accessory breast tissue with good results. “It can damage his feelings of masculinity and profoundly impact his self-esteem.”

Others, however, choose to celebrate their supernumerary self. 

“I’ve come to embrace it,” Mark Wahlberg told Rolling Stone magazine in 2005 when asked about his third nipple. “That thing’s my prized possession.”

Comments

If a woman had triplets an extra one may come in handy. I remember hearing that if you live to be seventy you can end up spending three years of your life waiting for things like in lines and stuff. If I was a triplet I sure wouldn't want to be last in line.
I think this is my new favorite article of all-time!
I think Carrie Underwood also has/had a third nipple.  At least she said so during her American Idol audition....
I'd like to meet a women with extra female parts. Indaviualality
is what makes us who we are. The wonders of nature far exceed anything man could come up with. I'll rather be with a lady with extra parts than one with an atom bomb. I'm probably stating the facts wrong, but u get the idea.
I seem to remember a bit of dialog in one of the Sean Connery James Bond films. A third nipple on a man was considered in Voodoo culture to be a sign of sexual prowness. It has been 20 years since I have seen that, but it stuck with me as I have a third nipple myself. - small with no areola. It has never come up with a lover before, but I always associated it as  "plus" based on the movie.
Anyone remember the episode of Friends with Chandler and his extra nipple?
I think a third breast could be a real asset to a girl if she had it in the right place.  You know, on her back, for dancing!
I used to be acquainted with a man in Louisiana who had six additional nipples.  His usual two pectoral areas were completely normal.  The additional six nipples, three per side, extended symmetrically in two straight lines down his stomach which seemed to be the "perfect" arrangement as for other polythelial mammals (in his case without additional areola).  Not all of his additional nipples were equally fully formed; they appeared more as protuberant moles, but their orientation made it clear to me what they were.  We became acquainted at a nudist park and he didn't seem to be the least self conscious about his extra "nips".  There didn't seem to be any enlargement or swelling around any of his extra nipples so apparently there was little or nil extra mammary tissue.  I suppose it might have been considerably different if he were female. If it were me, I think I'd probably be quite to very self-conscious and probably wouldn't have become a nudist.  I always felt so much the better for him.
I have always thought that a third breast on a woman would be ideal if it were placed in the middle of her back between the shoulders. It would make for something for her partner to hold onto while slow dancing. LOL
From now on, all women shall have 8 breasts.
Two breasts just aren't enough anymore.
That's not mutation, that's evolution!!!
This is my favorite article ever...mostly for the wild comments...Im thinking I have a hard enough time juggling two at the gym....I dont need any more.  And I love the term "accessory" which sounds almost like a positive thing, like "ooohhh I just love your new accessory breast"...weird.  Im thinking if I had one on the back of my leg I would definately have it removed asap....regardless of my gender or pain it caused me.
Re: Bond movie, "Man with the Golden Gun", leading character Scaramanga claimed extra nipple on chest.
I'd love to see women with more breasts.  You can never have too much of a good thing.
When our daughter, Brookelyn, was 5 months old, we discovered she had a "3rd nipple/breast"...needless to say we were horrified/embarrassed for her.  The dr. told us is was not that uncommon and are usually hereditary-he also said in medical school he learned this joke "what do glasses of wine and breast have in commom?"  "two's not enough and 3's too many" OY!
when we told my husband's family about this "3rd nipple/breast" the next month at Eastertime...my sister-in-law proceeded to raise her shirt..and in the same area as our daughter...she, too, had the "3rd nipple/breast"....Brookelyn is now 11 years old, and she reminds her daddy of this...."thanks Dad...for the family trait" hehehe
Al Bundy had it right when he said the ideal woman would have three breasts. One on the back for dancing.
I'd like to check out Carrie Underwood, thoroughly, just to see if she has one.
I had a dream once that a breast grew out of my side. Freaked me out.
Just a funny tidbit...I had a co-worker that had a fairly good sized mole on the side of her neck. When my granddaughter came in the office to visit...she was about 2...she asked her "what is that? A nipple?" So we always teased the co-worker about her extra nipple.
I had a 3rd breast, but had it removed after going through two pregnancies.  It was in my armpit and totally uncomfortable with hormone changes. Myself and both of my sons have just a hint of an extra nipple about 3" below the natural nipple.  I used to tell them that it was where cupid's arrow struck them.
I have a male friend who used to joke about how nice it would be for him to have a breast in each armpit that he could hold without other people knowing what he was doing. Now I wonder if he really does....
I worked with a nurse in northern California in the late 80's and early 90's who had a third nipple, slightly below the left one and more toward the sternum.
Many years ago I had a third nipple removed. I saw the doctor to have a large mole removed, he noticed the nipple and asked if I wanted it removed. So I did. My bras always slipped up, but after the surgery I felt "normal" and my bras stayed in place.
My daughter told me sevral years ago that she had read an article about this subject.  When I told my husband about it, he laughed and told me that it was ridiculous.  Can you believe it?  He was the one who sent this article to me.  I guess he's a believer, after all.

In High school we had a girl that had two vagina's and apparently she was able to have sex with either of them. No word on if she was able to get pregnant twice.
I have a third nipple.  It's no big deal.  It's just a dark spot that looks like it could almost be a mole.  I didn't even realize what it was until my daughter was born and I saw the exact same thing on her - in the exact same place!  I commented on it to her pediatrician, who told me what it was and confirmed that's what I had.  Now I use it as the butt of as many jokes as I can.
I have polymastia under both arm pits. This past June I was diagonised with Breast Cancer. I had to have a Double Mascetomy with a very uncommon kind of cancer,,,so this can be a very serious condition.
So that chick from the movie 'Total Recall' was for real!
And here I thought I was special..hmm turns out its not uncommon. Yet still uncomfortable to speak out...does it really turn guys on?
My daughter had a little place under one breast, that looked like a 'chicken pock' scar or a dimple, but she was born with it. The doc told us it was an accessory breast. As she got older, we noticed she had some darker, thicker skin under her breast, armpit around to her side/back area. When she was an infant, it was right around where your hand would hold her under her arm. When she was a toddler, a bit of it was right at the crease of her armpit and as she was more active it would crack and rub raw so we took her to a dermatoligist to see what it was. Yep, sure enough, breast tissue! He told us it could 'grow with her' and continue to cover as much of her body as it did then, or it might 'shrink' as she grew. We could always come and get it removed if it bothered her too much. Luckily, it stayed the same size, NOT growing as she did, it was finally just a little patch of darker skin on her back/side and under the breast a bit. The bad thing was, she also had a breast deformity, and had 3 surgeries to correct. Most of the fiberous tissue was removed, and she got implants at the age of 17. Because of the deformity, the 'bad tissue' hurt much more than usual for a young girl every month. Her cousin (on my husband's side) also was born with that 'dimple' on her chest. So, I guess it does run in families.
Yes...it is true ~ YOU CAN GROW EXTRA NIPPLES! Gross but OH SO TRUE. When I was pregnant with my first child I grew one under my armpit. I did not even realize it was there until one evening I was lying on the bed propped up on one arm reading a book when I noticed the bed was wet under my arm. Well I could not figure out how it got wet when it was not wet when I propped my arm up to read my book. I glanced up to the ceiling and there of course was nothing leaking from the ceiling when I then noticed my underarm was damp too. I had on a sleevless top and I felt under my arm and there it was.  This mole like thing leaking milk. I had never noticed it was under my arm, it was like it grew over night. FREAKED ME OUT! I could not imagine what it was.  Then I panicked! Well, I rushed to the doctor as soon as I could and he told me it was a nipple.  OH, I was totally grossed out and embarrassed! He said it was not uncommon for anyone to have extra nipples especially for a woman to grow them when she is pregnant. He preceded to say that he  had seen women when they are pregnant to grow six to eight of them up and down the stomach just like a dog does.  Well, that is when I was ready to leave the doctors office.  He removed the nipple and it has never grown back. I have a small scar under my armpit to remind me.  But then with my next child...here we go again under the other arm.   I  had it removed too.  This time I knew what it was and it was not a mole.  YUK!  So there you go!  It does happen! To the best of us!  LOL!!!!
Too often I have heard it said, "More than a handful is a waste".
I say, 'more than a handful' is why we have two hands.
Wow!!!
CHUCK  was her name sally ?
I have a third nipple on my penis. Oh no, it is my penis.
Actully  I've got a second pair of nipples,non developed on  me since I'm male , though I write in , mostly becasue at the hospital where I was born a girl was born  whom had  , a row of eight pairs of nipples  along her chest. WOuldn't I love to look her up now lol
This one time i went to the doctor and when i had my exam my doctor noticed the extra tissue in both of my armpits. Thats when i found that i had extra breast tissue there. Theres never been nipples but once i had kids thats when they became a problem. Ive been to doctors to have the extra tissue removed but all of them said it would be more painful to have them removed due to that my milk line is there and ive had 3 kids. So ive just adapted so to speak with them since then.
My gynecologist diagnosed what I always thought was a small wart under one breast as a nipple. He though it was funny. I wondered if it had anything to do with the animal kingdom. Both my children have the same small nip and it seems other members of my family also have it. I still wonder though.
Now Im going to the bathroom and scan my entire body for an extra nipple! Including my feet!
I have a 3rd nipple, right below the breast tissue on my right side.  I used to be very self-conscious about it, especially in school when showering after gym class.  Now I'm old and don't care what other people think.  It doesn't bother me, other than if I wear an underwire bra.
my best friend has a third nipple, kind of on his ribcage.  We went to a Less Than Jake concert once, and the band dedicated a song to anyone with a third nipple.  Based on the response, it's either really common or there were a bunch of wishful thinkers
My husband and daughter have a third nipple in the exact same place. Evidently it's hereditary.
I remember 1968 and Basic at Fort Jackson... We had a guy from Boston who had the 2 God gave everyone and if you looked down his chest to his belly , you would see no less than 6 symetrically placed nipples. The further down , the less noticable but.. you knew what they were. He was responsible for a lot of "Free" Beers in Columbia *S*.
Some women have all the luck!
When God created woman
He gave her not two breasts but three
When the middle one got in the way
God performed surgery
Woman stood before God
With the middle breast in her hand
And said "What do we do with the useless boob?"
And God created man
From the song "Bad Jokes" by Garrison Keeler
Most of these deformed (evolved) boobs end up in congress.  I'm thinking it is time to outlaw the existence or development of extra boobs, we have quite enough already!!! and it costs us a lot of money to keep them from sagging and even more to have them removed!!!!!
Where can one find the pictures of these extra nipples? For medical research they must b e somewhere. I'd especially would like to see the one of the one located in the perineum area! I wonder how much of a hassle their insurance company gave them when it came to paying that claim.
In our family,we have a superfluous nipple that is past down through generations. Both males and females inherit this birth mark randomly . It is a non-functional nipple that is flat and no breast behind it. When my grandson was born with one, ahhh we were proud!
I think it's George Bush's fault.
I read this and think back to when my first wife was nursing our children.  Can't help but wonder what kind of trajectory she would gain with an extra "leaker" in the armpit.   Come on, girls,,,,, Give it a squeeze!!!!!


Send a comment

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Your name, city and state (John Doe, Seattle, Wash.): 

Your e-mail address (jdoe@msnbc.com):

Your website (it's okay if you don't have one):

Remember me? (We'll keep it private)

About the blog

Insights and ruminations on the strangeness of all things medical, pharmaceutical and biological.

Msnbc.com writers and editors will muse upon the wonderfully weird human body and the medical curiosities that make you go huh, ewww or ouch! Looking for informed, unhinged meditations on everything from dubious diseases to recipes for ersatz mucous? Well, this is the place.

If you have a question, e-mail The Body Odd.

Archives


Add this blog to your news reader